10 Reasons Football Should Be Banned in Schools

10 Reasons Football Should Be Banned in Schools.
10 Reasons Football Should Be Banned in Schools.

10 Reasons Football Should Be Banned in Schools

 

In 2012 Dr. Paul Butler, a board member at Dover High School, New Hampshire, stirred up controversy when he suggested that the school’s football program should be terminated. Dr. Butler was not speaking as a critic of the game; the soft-spoken yet stocky retiree used to play football at high school and college. But the growing mass of literature testifying to the game’s negative neurological effects had instilled in him a sense of responsibility as custodian for the wellbeing and education of the younger generation. Nor has Butler’s been the only voice suggesting football’s removal from American high schools; two University of Minnesota doctors, Dr. Steven Miles and Dr. Shailendra Prasad, recently set out exactly the same position.

 

The heresy of such suggestions, and the ludicrously disproportionate media witch-hunts that always follow, reveal just how much of a tinderbox the issue is. Writing in the New York Times, Paul Brownfield didn’t exaggerate when calling Butler’s comment entry into ‘a 21st century culture war.’ Indeed the sport is, despite the lip service paid to baseball, unquestionably the nation’s favorite. But there is a real and serious problem with its practice in high schools.

 

A 2013 research paper into head impact exposure in youth football estimated that there are 1.1 million children in the US playing high school football (compared to 100,000 playing college football and 2,000 playing at a professional level). Knowing that football has far higher concussion rates than any other high school sport, this presents a clear problem. The author of this list believes that football – for all of its cultural, commercial and entertainment value – should be banned in schools. Here are 10 reasons why.

 10. The physical damage it causes is indisputable

Football causes serious injuries and should be banned.
Football causes serious injuries and should be banned.

When Dr. Bennet Omalu – recently immortalized in the Hollywood biopic Concussion – performed an autopsy on the late Pittsburgh Steelers center Mike Webster in 2002, he was shocked by the injuries he found. Nicknamed ‘Iron Mike’ because of his durability, Webster’s body showed signs of a daily maintenance routine that would have made the terminator feel uneasy: using superglue to reattach teeth, duct taping his disfigured feet to make walking bearable and popping vast quantities of Ritalin to perform the most basic of everyday tasks.

 

Of course Webster was an NFL professional, maybe even one of the all time greatest. His injuries, therefore, were exceptional and mostly incomparable with most of those sustained by high school football players. Injuries are, however, a common and accepted accompaniment to the game of football. As revealed in this American Academy of Pediatrics article into tackling in youth football, injuries to the knee, ankle, hand and back are the most common amongst high school footballers, with the head and neck faring comparatively better (at only between 5 percent to 13 percent of injuries). Most research suggests that youth footballers receive fewer injuries than their collegiate counterparts, though the data is inconsistent. What is universally accepted, however, is that regular sub-concussive contact and technically poor and illegal tackling can lead to serious physical injury. And although the frequency of severe and catastrophic injuries (especially to the head and neck) is relatively low, more of these injuries are sustained in football than in any other team sport.

 9. The psychological damage is substantial

Football cause psychological harm as well.
Football cause psychological harm as well.

Mike Webster was not the only former NFL player that Bennet posthumously analyzed last decade. In 2006, the neuropathologist received brain tissue samples from the recently deceased Philadelphia Eagles and Arizona Cardinals defender Andre Waters. Both Webster and Waters were found to have been suffering from similar post-concussive symptoms. The difference was that whereas Webster had died from a heart attack, aged 50, Waters had shot himself in the chest in a particularly violent act of suicide.

 

Omalu’s tests found that Waters’ 44-year-old brain had degenerated so much that it resembled the brain of a 90-year-old man. Undoubtedly as a direct result, he had been suffering from depression and exhibited characteristics of an early onset Alzheimer’s so severe that Waters would have been completely incapacitated had he lived another 10 years. There are other examples: Junior Seau, who also shot himself in the chest in 2012, exhibited signs of hyper-aggression, being convicted on charges of domestic assault. Dave Duerson, who died the same way a month prior, manifested a cognitive decline grossly inconsistent with his academic record in the years before his death.

 

Nor are such symptoms exclusive to NFL professionals. Behavior amongst those who played high school football can include severe depression, suicidal thoughts and actions, loss of memory, early onset dementia and significantly increased chances of drug and alcohol abuse for those in their 20s, 30s and 40s. In fact, these are not institutionally indoctrinated behavioral patterns at all. As has been discovered over the last ten years or so, they are instead clinical symptoms of a progressive degenerative disease known as Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy (CTE).

 8. CTE

Football and CTE and linked!
Football and CTE and linked!

First diagnosed in footballers by Bennet Omalu in 2002, CTE is an incurable and cognitively degenerative disease that can only be posthumously diagnosed following a cerebral autopsy. Because it’s a recent discovery, much still remains unknown. We do know, however, that although it’s extremely rare amongst the general population, it has been found in far greater numbers amongst people who have been involved in contact sports. Indeed as of 2014, 59 cases of CTE had been discovered in the brains of 62 ex-NFL players. But most worryingly, the earliest evidence of CTE was found not in the brain of an NFL athlete but in the brain of an 18-year-old high school student.

 

According to Omalu and other concussion experts, rather than being caused by individual undiagnosed high-impact concussions, CTE results from the normal sub-concussive hits that are part and parcel of the game. And the preconditions for CTE are not limited to the collegiate or professional game, as confirmed by a study published in the Journal of Neurotrauma into the presence of abnormal white matter in the brains of high school varsity footballers. To summarize, scientists were able to see noticeable increases in DTI (Diffusion Tensor Imaging) measures in the brains of those exposed to cumulative impacts. After a single season of high school football, MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging) changes were observable that had previously only been associated with mild traumatic brain injuries. Finally, the study confirmed an association between participation on high school football, sustaining of cumulative head impacts and a decline in post-seasonal cognitive functionality. In other words, kids who played football couldn’t function as well as they should.

7. Concussion

Football = concussions.
Football = concussions.

Go into any store and purchase a Schutt Sports helmet – or failing that just logon to their website – and you’ll be faced with either a sticker or a warning message reading: ‘No helmet can protect you from serious brain and/or neck injuries including paralysis and death. To avoid these risks, do not engage in the sport of football.’

 

Helmets were only made mandatory by the NCAA in 1939 and by the NFL in 1943, and it’s beyond dispute that in terms of design and durability they have come a long way since then. But as the Schutt message makes clear, no helmet on sale is protective enough. And with statistics from the sports concussion institute revealing that 1.6 to 3.8 million concussions occur annually and that of all sports football is the most likely to lead to concussion for males (with 75 percent of players getting concussed), we need to rethink our young’s participation in this sport.

 

A professional football player is estimated to receive between 900 to 1500 head blows each season; a staggering figure. What is more staggering is that high concussive rates are by no means confined to professional football, meaning that, as retired NFL defensive back Keith Smith recently said, ‘in terms of youth and high school football we’re in a race against the clock.’ Data from the Brain Injury Research Institute has revealed that in a single season a staggering 20 percent of high school footballers sustain some form of brain injury. What is sickening is that 40.5 percent of high school athletes that have sustained concussions are prematurely given the green light to return to the field – something that can quite easily cause fatality from Second Impact Syndrome (SIS).

6. Children’s brains are not fully developed

A child's brain is especially susceptible to the dangers of football.
A child’s brain is especially susceptible to the dangers of football.

The effects of concussion and CTE may well be amplified in the brain of a child. As outlined by neurologist Larry Robbins, children’s brains are structurally different to those of adults, lacking both the protective covering of nerve cells (myelin) and the foundational support of strong neck muscles. Nor is Robbins alone in suggesting that the effects of repetitive head trauma could be more serious for children. CTE discoverer and NFL bogeyman Bennet Omalu has called for children to be prevented from playing football until they reach 18, putting the sport’s risk in the same bracket as alcohol, tobacco and asbestos, while Boston University School of Medicine professor and senior advisor to the NFL and NFL Players Association Robert Cantu has argued that children should be held back from all contact sports until they reach 14. Considering the fact that 70 percent of those who play football in the US are under 14, it’s not hard to see why.

 

With mounting statistical data, those who argue against contact being removed from the youth game rely on increasingly flimsy arguments. The first is that it’s vital to teach correct tackling technique at a young age before increases in the size and strength of players makes it a more dangerous endeavor. Yet John Gagliardi removed tackling from practice in 1956 and went on to become college football’s most successful ever coach. The only logical argument, therefore, comes down to entertainment. Football is a game for the spectators viewing pleasure in which high impact tackles are the main event and unless the craft is taught at a young age, the end result at professional level won’t be the same. The key difference here is that NFL players have made the bed in which they lie in.